The Globe and Mail Review

[Auburn Annie]

Gord and his baritone are thin, but he's back

By JAMES ADAMS

Thursday, May 19, 2005


Gordon Lightfoot at Massey Hall, Toronto

A famous critic once described jazz as "the sound of surprise." There wasn't much jazz at Massey Hall last night (the chord changes in Beautiful notwithstanding) or much surprise. But there was much pleasure and not a little pathos as Gordon Lightfoot once again trod upon the hall's fabled boards as he has so famously done, off and on, for the last 38 years.

Mr. Lightfoot, in fact, hasn't graced the grand old lady of Shuter Street since May of 2001. He was last scheduled to play a series of dates there in the fall of 2002, but then an abdominal aneurysm that September put him seriously out of commission. For the next 19 months and 22 days, fans wondered if Canada's most famous troubadour would survive the three operations he eventually had, and if he did survive, would he be able to perform again.

The answer came in the form of 27 songs expertly played over more than two hours before an adoring crowd of about 2,700. At 66, Gord is back -- a little short of wind, his baritone thin on the top end, his body almost spookily thin, and the face carved into stark planes, but back nevertheless.

Indeed, it took a while last night for one to sense that -- 14 songs and one intermission, to be precise -- but once Mr. Lightfoot and his veteran four-piece band appeared for the second set, all seemed right between performer and audience.

Of course, there was nothing radical about last night's concert. A Lightfoot performance is nothing if not a celebration of the pleasures of the predictable as Mr. Lightfoot and band -- bassist Rick Haynes (who's been with him for 36 years), guitarist Terry Clements (35 years), drummer Barry Keane (29 years) and keyboardist Mike Heffernan (at Mr. Lightfoot's right hand for 18 years) -- serve up one familiar song after another, interspersed with material that at first seems lesser-known songs then familiar all the same.

Unsurprisingly, the mostly older audience (at intermission, I stood in line, a long, long line, to the men's washroom with a Lightfoot acquaintance from New York who remarked that he should have worn Depends) was on Mr. Lightfoot's side right from the moment he joined his bandmates on stage around 8:10 p.m. "Sorry I'm late," he joked as the crowd, which included Governor-General Adrienne Clarkson and John Ralston Saul, responded with a standing ovation of whoops, whistles and handclaps that lasted more than two minutes.

The first set, a mixture of gems (Cotton Jenny, Minstrel of the Dawn, Sundown) and clunkers (including a relatively new song, Couchiching, from last year's Harmony CD that is better left forgotten or else sold as a jingle for the Orillia Chamber of Commerce), seemed rather strained and tentative as all concerned tried to find their bearings and adjust their expectations.

But a sense of both relaxation and purposefulness eventually settled on both Mr. Lightfoot and his associates, something especially evident in their assaying of classics such as If You Could Read My Mind, A Painter Passing Through, Ghost of Cape Horn, Baby Step Back and Beautiful.

Here lines such as, "And after all is said and done/is there no rainbow's end," and, "To be just once again/With you," carried an added poignancy and greater intimations of mortality as a result of Mr. Lightfoot's tribulations of recent years.

Of course, the big question on most of the audience's mind was, would he do Canadian Railroad Trilogy, perhaps his most epic and most challenging (at least in terms of duration) song? Well, he did, as the first of what were two encores (the last was another chestnut, Bitter Green). It was pretty good, if strained in the later going. In fact, the drama here was found less in the grandiose lyrics and more in the audience's prayers that the singer would get through the composition more or less intact.

Which he did. Because Mr. Lightfoot clearly felt the love last night. There's nothing, it seems, like a near-death experience to deepen one's appreciation of old friendships, sturdy craftsmanship and the grace of sheer perseverance.

[Auburn Annie]

Gord and his baritone are thin, but he's back

By JAMES ADAMS

Thursday, May 19, 2005


Gordon Lightfoot at Massey Hall, Toronto

A famous critic once described jazz as "the sound of surprise." There wasn't much jazz at Massey Hall last night (the chord changes in Beautiful notwithstanding) or much surprise. But there was much pleasure and not a little pathos as Gordon Lightfoot once again trod upon the hall's fabled boards as he has so famously done, off and on, for the last 38 years.

Mr. Lightfoot, in fact, hasn't graced the grand old lady of Shuter Street since May of 2001. He was last scheduled to play a series of dates there in the fall of 2002, but then an abdominal aneurysm that September put him seriously out of commission. For the next 19 months and 22 days, fans wondered if Canada's most famous troubadour would survive the three operations he eventually had, and if he did survive, would he be able to perform again.

The answer came in the form of 27 songs expertly played over more than two hours before an adoring crowd of about 2,700. At 66, Gord is back -- a little short of wind, his baritone thin on the top end, his body almost spookily thin, and the face carved into stark planes, but back nevertheless.

Indeed, it took a while last night for one to sense that -- 14 songs and one intermission, to be precise -- but once Mr. Lightfoot and his veteran four-piece band appeared for the second set, all seemed right between performer and audience.

Of course, there was nothing radical about last night's concert. A Lightfoot performance is nothing if not a celebration of the pleasures of the predictable as Mr. Lightfoot and band -- bassist Rick Haynes (who's been with him for 36 years), guitarist Terry Clements (35 years), drummer Barry Keane (29 years) and keyboardist Mike Heffernan (at Mr. Lightfoot's right hand for 18 years) -- serve up one familiar song after another, interspersed with material that at first seems lesser-known songs then familiar all the same.

Unsurprisingly, the mostly older audience (at intermission, I stood in line, a long, long line, to the men's washroom with a Lightfoot acquaintance from New York who remarked that he should have worn Depends) was on Mr. Lightfoot's side right from the moment he joined his bandmates on stage around 8:10 p.m. "Sorry I'm late," he joked as the crowd, which included Governor-General Adrienne Clarkson and John Ralston Saul, responded with a standing ovation of whoops, whistles and handclaps that lasted more than two minutes.

The first set, a mixture of gems (Cotton Jenny, Minstrel of the Dawn, Sundown) and clunkers (including a relatively new song, Couchiching, from last year's Harmony CD that is better left forgotten or else sold as a jingle for the Orillia Chamber of Commerce), seemed rather strained and tentative as all concerned tried to find their bearings and adjust their expectations.

But a sense of both relaxation and purposefulness eventually settled on both Mr. Lightfoot and his associates, something especially evident in their assaying of classics such as If You Could Read My Mind, A Painter Passing Through, Ghost of Cape Horn, Baby Step Back and Beautiful.

Here lines such as, "And after all is said and done/is there no rainbow's end," and, "To be just once again/With you," carried an added poignancy and greater intimations of mortality as a result of Mr. Lightfoot's tribulations of recent years.

Of course, the big question on most of the audience's mind was, would he do Canadian Railroad Trilogy, perhaps his most epic and most challenging (at least in terms of duration) song? Well, he did, as the first of what were two encores (the last was another chestnut, Bitter Green). It was pretty good, if strained in the later going. In fact, the drama here was found less in the grandiose lyrics and more in the audience's prayers that the singer would get through the composition more or less intact.

Which he did. Because Mr. Lightfoot clearly felt the love last night. There's nothing, it seems, like a near-death experience to deepen one's appreciation of old friendships, sturdy craftsmanship and the grace of sheer perseverance.

[johnfowles]

Well not alright..we unfortuneately had to return home today but are returning to Tronno on Saturday
Lots of familiar faces at the after concert party last night at the Delta Chelsea (only a
couple blocks north of Massey and on the left opposite Sam's records on Yonge Street a
sumpotious party thanks to the generosity of Janice fropm California in a room organised at
great personal grief/trauma and determination by Jenney Rivard. I thought I would rush
this out as Janice had sent out a limited citrculation email to those she knew were going
to attend. so please anybody that missed that go to the Delta Chelsea after Saturday's concert and
ask to phone Janice Ross' room and then come up to enjoy the fun and conmradeship
---------------------------------------------
Added Friday Oops I wrote the above in a hurry then rather later realised that I had not told the whole story about gatherings. In her smail Janice also said
"On Saturday, in addition to the post concert party, we are arranging for a pre-concert gathering over dinner at City Grill in Eaton Centre ( http://city.celebrationgrills.ca/Menus.html)"
I also meant to enquire if I was going to be lucky enough to meet some other notables who just might be at Saturday's concert and or the party and/or at the pre-concert dinner:-
In particular the Watchman, and the Stationmaster


John Fowles
I Meant no one No harm
As for the concert on Wednedsday the reviewer who was mean about Coouchiching got it utterly and
completely wrong the Silly A..IMHO it most certainly did not come over as a "clunker" and I think the audience enjoyed Gord's singing it as much as he obviously relished performong the tribute to Orillia
sorry I was not able to make set list and no doubt somebody else will post one in due course

[ May 20, 2005, 14:13: Message edited by: johnfowles ]

[johnfowles]

Well not alright..we unfortuneately had to return home today but are returning to Tronno on Saturday
Lots of familiar faces at the after concert party last night at the Delta Chelsea (only a
couple blocks north of Massey and on the left opposite Sam's records on Yonge Street a
sumpotious party thanks to the generosity of Janice fropm California in a room organised at
great personal grief/trauma and determination by Jenney Rivard. I thought I would rush
this out as Janice had sent out a limited citrculation email to those she knew were going
to attend. so please anybody that missed that go to the Delta Chelsea after Saturday's concert and
ask to phone Janice Ross' room and then come up to enjoy the fun and conmradeship
---------------------------------------------
Added Friday Oops I wrote the above in a hurry then rather later realised that I had not told the whole story about gatherings. In her smail Janice also said
"On Saturday, in addition to the post concert party, we are arranging for a pre-concert gathering over dinner at City Grill in Eaton Centre ( http://city.celebrationgrills.ca/Menus.html)"
I also meant to enquire if I was going to be lucky enough to meet some other notables who just might be at Saturday's concert and or the party and/or at the pre-concert dinner:-
In particular the Watchman, and the Stationmaster


John Fowles
I Meant no one No harm
As for the concert on Wednedsday the reviewer who was mean about Coouchiching got it utterly and
completely wrong the Silly A..IMHO it most certainly did not come over as a "clunker" and I think the audience enjoyed Gord's singing it as much as he obviously relished performong the tribute to Orillia
sorry I was not able to make set list and no doubt somebody else will post one in due course

[ May 20, 2005, 14:13: Message edited by: johnfowles ]

[The Rez]

John,

A note from Balboa. When my son, Joshua, heard Coouchichingienginaidngieikero on The Harmony CD, he immediately cited it as his personal favorite. Josh is 35 and has been w/ me for many a show of Gord's (w/ his 2 bros)

That made me smile. Gord, too.

The Rez