[spocksbrain]

I have heard some modern shows and some vintage ones with just the three piece format. I am also used to the synth and drums being there. I am curious as to which some of us prefer. I like both just about equally. The songs have a different personality when performed in the three piece format. Especially in the 1960's, Gordon played with much more urgency. Red's fills were brilliant.

When he plays in the three piece format these days, it sounds a great deal more laid back. Gord strums his guitar with generally half the licks than he used in the 60's and with the exception of Don Quixote, Terry's leads seem to be exactly the same as with the five piece band (not a criticism, just an observation- I think Terry's understated way of playing has become one of the key pleasures of hearing a Lightfoot show).