My choice is most likely jaded by the fact that I've heard,"The Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald" for nearly 30 years and also for my love of '70s music. So,"Wreck" it is.
"Yarmouth" is pretty good but it just doesn't resonate to my senses the way the other does. "Wreck" is something I can actually picture,since my folks and I used to go to the great Lakes when I was little,mostly Lake Erie.
Count it,1 vote for "Wreck".